Wider World
An Open Letter to the World on Antisemitism
Editor’s Note: The following piece, initiated by the Jewish News in London in partnership with The Jerusalem Post, is being published simultaneously in Jewish media around the world.
Two decades ago, the former British chief rabbi, Lord Jonathan Sacks, astutely likened antisemitism to a constantly evolving virus. One that, in the modern era, specifically targets the Jewish nation-state.
He aptly described this prejudice as a deeply ingrained malignancy, perpetually lingering beneath the surface of society. For many of us in the global Jewish community, the great man’s words were not merely a statement of truth but also a stark reminder. Until recent days, the extent and intensity of this virulent strain of hatred were tragically underestimated.
While the need for stringent security measures at schools and synagogues has long been a familiar reality, the realization that such profound levels of hatred and indifference to the threat exists on a global scale has been a devastating shock.
We dared to hope such malevolence had been relegated to the annals of history.
Today, in an unprecedented moment in Jewish history, we unite as Jewish news outlets spanning borders, continents and religious affiliations to issue this open letter—something we never envisioned as necessary or even conceivable.
The events of recent weeks have surpassed even the somber portrayal offered by Rabbi Sacks all those years ago. Some of those who propagate hatred, concealing their prejudice under the veneer of being “anti-Israel,” no longer find it necessary to obscure their malice.
We’ve witnessed raw hatred against Jews in cities across the globe:
- In Dagestan, a mob ran toward planes on a runway to check passengers’ passports, hunting for disembarking Jews.
- In Sydney, when authorities lit the famous opera house in the colors of Israel’s flag, a crowd sang “Gas the Jews.”
- In Lyon, France, a woman was stabbed at her home, and a swastika was spray-painted on her front door.
- In London, red paint was daubed on Jewish school doors and the Wiener Holocaust Library.
- In Berlin, Magen Davids have been spray painted on homes, a haunting echo of scenes in that German city 90 years ago.
- And in the United States, on campuses across the country, “martyrs” who butchered Jewish children in their beds on October 7 are being celebrated and a student at Cornell University was arrested for posting death threats against Jews.
These incidents are not calls for two states living side by side in peace. This is not legitimate opposition to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his government.
How could we have been so blind to this malignancy in our midst? And yet, all that we have seen so far isn’t even our worst fear. Our gravest concerns lie in what the future may hold.
Meanwhile, some world leaders act as cheerleaders, sometimes inadvertently but at other times, not. Colombia’s president Gustavo Petro said: “If I had lived in Germany of 1933, I would have fought on the side of the Jewish people, and if I had lived in Palestine in 1948, I would have fought on the Palestinian side.”
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said: “Hamas is not a terrorist organization.”
The head of the United Nations, Antonio Guterres, said October 7 “didn’t happen in a vacuum.”
No, it didn’t, Mr. Guterres. It required decades of indoctrination, years of holding up terrorists as heroes to be lionized, a sure way to fame and, often, fortune, and the presence of a terrorist organization whose central aim is to wipe Israel—and every one of our Jewish family and friends—off the face of the earth.
Have no doubt that Hamas is cheering those “from the river to the sea” chants because a Palestine from the river to the sea leaves not a single inch for Israel.
Why do so many still seek to deny what’s in Hamas’s own charter?
And why are so many good people still silent when cheerleaders for terrorists decide the worst massacre of our co-religionists since the Holocaust is a good moment to open up a second global front targeting Jews on campus, at work, on the streets and at home?
Clearly not everyone marching under the Palestinian flag fantasizes about our deaths or the destruction of the world’s only Jewish state.
But please, try to understand that whether it’s one person, 100 people or 10,000, the chilling impact of seeing so many people echo and excuse hateful chants is profound.
It’s not easy to speak on behalf of Jews in one country, never mind the world, nor do we purport to. As journalists, we report, opine and comment. But the level of fear among our readers is like nothing in memory. It feels as if those two equilateral triangles that combine to form our beloved Star of David represent a six-pointed target.
This is heightened by the fact there will be those who dismiss every word in this piece as having been written in bad faith, part no doubt of our supposed control of power and the media that has manipulated their warped minds. There will also be Jews who tell you this article doesn’t speak for them. Before those in the media feel the urge to put them on the airwaves in an attempt at “balance,” please first ask for an ounce of proof that they represent more than a tiny band of misfits. Some are more likely to stand alongside the Iranian regime that is so despised by much of the Muslim world than they would with most Jews.
Please don’t, however, mistake this growing fear for a lack of determination to fight for our corner as citizens deserving of support and protection in our home nations—or doubt our solidarity as a people numbering just 16 million. In fact, we’ve never been so determined, so energized, so united and so proud, as highlighted by the huge uptick in sales of Stars of David.
The incredible response in holding rallies, supporting charities and fighting running battles on social media is something that will remain a source of pride for as long as we recall those horrific images from Kibbutz Beeri and the peace rave.
This unity has been a light in the darkness. Another has been the support, public and private, of our real friends in all communities. We will never forget this.
Our collective Jewish heart bleeds for the families of those who lost relatives in the Hamas atrocities and those facing agonizing waits for news of the kidnapped men, women and children. Whether directly or indirectly, many of our readers are connected to these innocents. But our hearts bleed, too, for the innocents killed in Gaza as a result of this entirely unnecessary war launched by Hamas.
Over the unbearably painful days ahead, we—as providers of news for secular and religious Jews, for those who frequently critique Israeli policy and those who don’t, for those who see Israel as central to their identity and those who are drawn nearer by crises such as this—call on the world to listen and treat us as you would want to be treated.
It shouldn’t be too much to ask.
Beverly Cadwell says
Amen!
Lutz Budde says
For evil to succeed, good people keep silent in face of evil. Said in many different ways, but it holds still. It is shameful that much of the world stands by, when Jews get killed in a planned attack. Have we’re nothing learned since 1945 when the full evil of the Nazis was shown to the whole world. Let’s challenge those who accommodate Hamas vileness.
Tamara Adrine-Davis says
I stand with world Jewry and the state of Israel. I don’t understand how so many of the people with whom I normally share Left-ish beliefs can support Hamas. I have SERIOUS problems with the current Israeli government, but I still support Israel 100%. And, by the way, I’m not Jewish. I’m a queer Black disabled woman who just happened to develop a deep appreciation for Jewish culture growing up.
I read a comment on one of the entertainment news websites the other day that nearly floored me. The writer, an executive in the movie industry who described himself as a “super Lefty,” lamented the betrayal he felt from his Left-leaning friends. Although he did not specifically say it, he made it clear that he felt specifically betrayed by Black people. He stated that he and other Lefty Jews had shown up numerous times for BLM, but when it was Jews who needed support, there were no Black people. Although I am not personally responsible for the actions/inactions of millions of Black people, I still felt this gentleman’s pain. I, too, am pained and bewildered. We, as Black people, should be standing shoulder-to-shoulder with our Jewish allies. We have mutual history.
I am only responsible for myself. Therefore, I can say for myself that I will stand in open, steadfast solidarity with the Jewish community. I hate that innocent people have been killed on both sides. But, honestly, I think angry Palestinians and their supporters need to put the blame on Hamas where it belongs. Israel had precisely zero good choices.
Karen Sabo says
Thank you for your solidarity and your words. As a Jew, I look at Goodman and Schwerner as martyrs along with Cheney and I’m grateful when Black Americans who aren’t even Jewish lend support. Love to you, sister.