American View
A New Project Aims to Preserve the Borscht Belt Legacy
While outsized in Jewish memory, Borscht Belt-era resorts and bungalows have largely vanished from New York’s Catskills landscape—a loss documented by artist Marisa Scheinfeld in her popular 2016 photo book, The Borscht Belt: Revisiting the Remains of America’s Jewish Vacationland. The book featured Scheinfeld’s images of the ghostly ruins of hotels and resorts that she had explored during her Catskills childhood in the 1980’s.
Now Scheinfeld aims to further honor that history with the Borscht Belt Historical Marker Project. Beginning this summer and continuing over several years, Scheinfeld and her project colleague, Borscht Belt historian Louis Inghilterra, plan to install roughly a dozen signs documenting bygone Jewish landmarks. Financial support is coming from local municipalities and the Jewish American Society for Historic Preservation, a volunteer group that has installed dozens of similar markers across the United States, from small towns like Wild Horse Butte, Utah, to cities such as Memphis, Tenn.
“We want the markers to be in town hubs, where there’s foot traffic,” explained Scheinfeld. “While we want to pay tribute to history, we also want people to engage with the renaissance of creative life in the Catskills.”
A stone’s throw from the vintage stores, wine shops and eateries, the new generation of Catskills leisure-goers can learn about their vacationing predecessors from the markers. Each one will have information about specific local landmarks on the front, Borscht Belt background on the reverse and a QR code that links visitors’ phones to the website of the Catskills Institute, an academic initiative at Northeastern University that promotes research and education on the importance of the upstate New York region to Jewish American life.
In Monticello, for instance, visitors to the Crawford Public Library courtyard will learn about Kutsher’s, Laurels and other hotels once located nearby. In Swan Lake, a lakeside setting will pay tribute to the erstwhile Stevensville Lake Hotel.
Scheinfeld and Inghilterra plan to inaugurate each installation with Catskills-related film screenings, photography exhibits, concerts and book talks. There is no shortage of such material, as the area’s renaissance has inspired new interest in its Jewish cultural heritage.
“Timing is everything,” Scheinfeld noted. “We’re trying to create something with longevity celebrating an era that’s important not only to Jews, but also to American culture.”
Hilary Danailova
Beth Friedman Smile says
Since most of the hotels are long gone how and where will the markers be placed? How is it decided which hotels will have markers? Since I am writing a book which contains a great deal of information on my grandfather’s hotel in S. Fallsburg, I would like to know how to get a marker to represent the area around where his hotel was. Thanks for any information that you can share with me..
Beth Friedman Smile
Karen Drayson Harper says
Is there going to be a mailing list to get information on the project and future activitolies.
Thank you very much.
Claire says
There’s a “subscribe” button at the bottom of the project’s website: https://borschtbelthistoricalmarkerproject.org/
Robin Kauffman says
Marisa is right, timing is everything.
As VP/Board Trustee for the soon to be announced CATSKILLS BORSCHT BELT MUSEUM (hint… this week April 16-21), I could not be more excited to see the extent of interest in preserving this wonderful era that changed the landscape of American history!
As my friend Barry Lewis said in his recent article in the Sullivan County Democrat (https://www.scdemocratonline.com/stories/the-catskills,91781?) “Instead of Hollywood telling us how to remember what the Catskills were supposed to be, we’ll soon be able to revisit and pay tribute to what the heyday of the Borscht Belt was really all about.”
Bert says
In addition to the hotels were the cottage colonies both Jewish and Italian. Any museum should have a video of the ride on rte 17 and the Wurtsboro Hill and the food stops. It would be nice if they could compile a list of the famous tumlers who broke in their acts in the hotels.
Blake Pfeil says
You can learn more about Marisa and this important project by listening to this special bonus episode of abandoned: The All-American Ruins Podcast, which will be released on Thursday, May 4: https://www.blakepfeil.com/aar-podcast.html